Disliking a film can be just as fruitful, and possibly more enjoyable, than adoring it.
A movie that is glaringly foolish, poorly conceived, or simply malevolent can spark just as much thought and conversation as one that is genuinely impactful. In either scenario, there’s at least something worth engaging with.
This is what makes encountering a film like The Social Reckoning so disheartening. The sequel to The Social Network, penned and directed by Aaron Sorkin—who also wrote the remarkable 2010 film about Facebook’s origins directed by David Fincher—stands as one of those rare, lamentable anti-art failures.
It is a movie so shallow and derivative that it evades genuine disdain, despite its attempts to present itself as perpetually relevant. Overall, it is such an infuriatingly dull experience that it lacks sufficient insight or perspective to disagree with, let alone to hate productively.
Given its focus on the perils of social media and the groupthink enforced by corporations, it could serve as a case study of the very issue Sorkin seeks to highlight: an abundance of low-quality, unengaging “content” filling our feeds and For You pages.
Yet, this mishandling of promising source material arises from a talented cast and crew comprising some of today’s most intriguing creatives.
The Social Reckoning traces Facebook’s era of relentless expansion and pledges to critique one of the three tech titans responsible for the current dystopia. (The other two are depicted in Alex Gibney’s documentary Musk, set to release in Canada on October 16, and Luca Guadagnino’s critique of Sam Altman/OpenAI, Artificial, which just premiered to enthusiastic reviews at the New York Film Festival.)
The unspoken marketing claim here is that this film is a sharp and timely piece that will enlighten viewers and challenge the status quo. However, rather than delivering Spotlight, we encounter a narrative where The Bear‘s Jeremy Allen White portrays Wall Street Journal journalist Jeff Horwitz, a reporter at a struggling (surprise, surprise) publication attempting to keep its audience from migrating to social media. Meanwhile, Anora‘s Mikey Madison takes on the role of Frances Haugen, a disillusioned product manager on Facebook’s civic misinformation team.
As expected, they swiftly connect and begin to unravel a covert cycle of misconduct known as MSI (Meaningful Social Interactions) that has been destabilizing governments, impairing minds, and undermining the essence of truth. Again, nothing new here.
In the interim, Jeremy Strong from Succession portrays the villainous Mark Zuckerberg, who is experiencing a significant fall from grace, both in the fictional world and in terms of his cinematic portrayal.
Here, Zuckerberg is preparing for an inquiry regarding his company’s role in the erosion of liberal democracy and the mental health crisis affecting children globally.
In comparison to Jesse Eisenberg’s nuanced, sharp, and endlessly captivating portrayal, which garnered him his sole acting Oscar nomination, this version of Zuckerberg appears more uninspired and poorly conceived than the Metaverse he envisioned.
Were it not for the quirky manner in which Strong accentuates the famously bizarre traits of a man who was once forced to publicly assert he was not a lizard, he would be almost entirely irrelevant to the story.

Mikey Madison, left, and Jeremy Allen White star in The Social Reckoning. (Leah Gallo/Sony Pictures/The Associated Press)
Aside from his alarmingly controlled demeanor reminiscent of a socially awkward praying mantis—and a hairstyle that falls somewhere between Fargo‘s Ole Munch and Starburst’s Berries and Cream man—this iteration of Zuckerberg remains largely in the shadows.
Zuckerberg’s motivations propelled the singular and straightforward original, transforming it into a compelling psychological character study. This time around, we gain almost nothing narratively from a man who instead lurks awkwardly in the background and in mostly inconsequential side scenes, unsettling us with sporadic reminders of his presence, only to reinforce that, in the grand scheme of things, he holds little sway over the unfolding events.
This is particularly evident in the context of a mundane, uniformly tedious, and unimaginably cliché narrative.
Sorkin’s portrayal of Zuckerberg functions like a cheap marketing ploy, merely an ornament meant to entice viewers to watch the frustrated yet enamored reporter Horwitz lead the determined, altruistic Haugen into conflict against the omnipotent figure behind the curtain. It resembles a novice screenwriter’s take on The Client, only with more technology involved.
This is not entirely Strong’s doing. Given his consistently pitiable and committed performance as Kendall Roy, alongside his scene-stealing turn as Trump’s fixer Roy Cohn in The Apprentice, we know that if there were any substantial narrative elements to explore here, he would have certainly unearthed them.
Instead, the responsibility lies clearly with Sorkin. For those who have already found the West Wing and Moneyball writer’s rapid, stylized dialogue and contrived scenarios to be grating, this will likely come as no revelation. However, even for those who appreciate the heightened reality of the Sorkinverse, The Social Reckoning is simply a letdown.
-
As The Social Reckoning hits theatres, Facebook whistleblower says the fight to rein in Big Tech continues
-
REVIEW
Tom Cruise is fantastic in Digger. You might hate it
Ultimately, we are left with a clumsy and overly sweet narrative that somehow both exploits and trivializes its timely and relevant themes. A meandering, self-indulgent patchwork of journalistic clichés that leads to White and Madison making direct references to other, superior journalism films in their dialogue.
The film concludes with an ending that is so incredibly, almost unbelievably trite that it gives the impression Sorkin was deliberately attempting to mock the sentimental closing text of Stand By Me.
However, the most disheartening aspect of The Social Reckoning isn’t any of these issues. It is the overwhelming and utter absence of risk, specificity, or purpose. It feels as though the film’s entire duration exists merely as a means to occupy time. It is also troubling that Sorkin—an Academy and Emmy award-winning writer—has produced something so thoroughly neutered that it scarcely invokes hatred.
This is especially disappointing when comparing it to its predecessor: while The Social Network utilized the founding of Facebook as a framework to delve into its creator’s psyche, Reckoning employs it merely as a backdrop to illustrate a Wikipedia entry that isn’t even particularly accurate.
Beyond the comparisons to its predecessor, Reckoning disappoints due to its lack of any elements to disapprove of. Its general blandness and timidity render it disappointing. And that, above all, is the most regrettable trait a work of art can possess.
Tag: rewrite-pending

