Dayne St. Clair bolstered his bid to become Canada’s top goalkeeper on Monday by being awarded the MLS Goalkeeper of the Year.
The Minnesota United goalkeeper outperformed New York City FC’s Matt Freese and Vancouver Whitecaps’ Yohei Takaoka in the voting conducted by technical staff from MLS clubs, first-team players, and selected media members.
St. Clair garnered 29.4 percent of the total votes, while Freese received 17.32 percent and Takaoka 15.49 percent.
In the media voting segment, St. Clair was a dominant choice, securing 47.46 percent of the votes, compared to Takaoka’s 11.30 percent and Freese’s 5.65 percent. Conversely, Freese and Takaoka led among players, each with 20.37 percent, while St. Clair followed closely with 18.52 percent. In the club voting, Freese took the lead with 25.93 percent, followed by St. Clair at 22.22 percent and Takaoka at 14.81 percent.
“This year has undoubtedly been my most consistent and best one so far,” stated St. Clair. “However, I recognize that I have not reached my full potential yet. I believe there is still room for improvement and that I can be even better than my current performance.”
This accolade adds to his achievements this season, which also included being named to the MLS All-Star team.
The 28-year-old from Pickering, Ontario, now joins Pat Onstad as the only Canadian to receive the MLS goalkeeper award. Onstad, who is currently the president of soccer operations for the Houston Dynamo, won the title in 2003 and 2005 while playing for the San Jose Earthquakes.
Maxime Crepeau, another contender for the Canadian starting goalkeeper position, placed fifth in the 2021 voting, while Greg Sutton ranked fourth in 2008.
An eye on the World Cup
St. Clair emphasizes the importance of focusing on the present as he prepares for next year’s World Cup.
“A World Cup, especially one hosted at home, is the stuff of dreams,” he remarked. “Particularly with the first match taking place in Toronto, my hometown, this is an opportunity that I know will not come again in my lifetime. It’s truly a unique chance.”
“I understand that this season, leading into the next, will significantly influence my role on the team there.”
St. Clair, who served as a backup to Milan Borjan during the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, has earned 17 caps for Canada, achieving eight clean sheets.
The Canadian men’s national team, currently ranked 28th, will conclude their 2025 schedule with matches against No. 23 Ecuador and No. 50 Venezuela on November 13 and 18 in Toronto and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, respectively.
St. Clair and Minnesota will face Seattle on Monday in the second game of their best-of-three first-round playoff series. Minnesota triumphed in the opener via a penalty shootout (3-2) after a goalless draw, with two Seattle players striking the woodwork.
Campaign to remember
Playing behind a Minnesota team that boasts the third-best defense in the league, allowing an average of 1.15 goals per game, the seven-year MLS veteran achieved regular-season records in saves (113) and shutouts (10), while also matching his seasonal best of 15 wins. He led the league with a save percentage of 77.9 percent and posted the second-best goals-against average at 1.00.
Among starting goalkeepers, St. Clair finished the regular season ranked seventh in wins, fourth in saves, and tied for fourth in shutouts.
The Loons managed to restrict their opponents to one goal or fewer in 23 out of their 34 regular-season matches, which included a 3-1 victory over San Diego FC on September 23, where St. Clair made a career-high 12 saves.
“We play with a very determined style, which involves every player giving their all defensively, allowing us to counter-attack from those defensive stands,” St. Clair explained.
Finishing fourth in the Western Conference with a record of 16-8-10, Minnesota set new franchise records for wins (16), points (58), and goals conceded (39). They also achieved their best-ever road record at 8-3-6 and marked their lowest loss total in a season with eight.
St. Clair joins Vito Mannone (2019) as the second player from Minnesota United to receive this prestigious award.
The club selected the six-foot-three goalkeeper in the first round (seventh overall) of the 2019 MLS SuperDraft from the University of Maryland.
St. Clair capped off his college career at Maryland by winning the NCAA championship, completing five tournament games without allowing a goal. He concluded his tenure as a Terrapin with a remarkable 500-minute shutout streak.
At the age of 15, St. Clair made his debut in the Canadian youth program in 2013 under coach Robert Gale. He made his senior debut at 24 in a World Cup qualifier, leading Canada to a 7-0 victory over Aruba in June 2022.
Initially starting as an outfield player, St. Clair transitioned to the goalkeeper position at 14. He honed his skills at Ajax FC under Dario Gasparotto, who is now a staff coach at FC Durham Academy, before joining the Vaughan Soccer Club.
