Trial Begins for Burlington Women Charged in 12-Year-Old’s Death

Date:

WARNING: This story contains details regarding allegations of child abuse.

A shocking trial in Ontario is currently taking place, where two women have entered pleas of not guilty to the first-degree murder of a 12-year-old boy they intended to adopt.

Residents of Burlington, Brandy Cooney and Becky Hamber, face additional charges that include confinement, weapon assault involving zip ties, and neglecting to provide the basic necessities of life for the boy’s younger sibling.

The deceased boy, referred to in court as L.L. to maintain his identity confidentiality due to a publication ban aimed at protecting his younger brother, identified as J.L., passed away on December 21, 2022. The precise cause of L.L.’s death has not yet been determined in the court proceedings.

The trial, which is being presided over by Justice Clayton Conlan, began last month in the Superior Court located in Milton, with the opening statement delivered by Crown attorney Kelli Frew.

“The brothers, L.L. and J.L., deserved a permanent home where they would receive love, care, and appreciation,” the attorney stated. “Instead, they ended up in the care of the accused, where they faced disdain, deprivation, and maltreatment.”

2 boys initially in Ottawa foster home

According to the agreed statement of facts, the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) relocated the Indigenous boys from their long-standing foster care in Ottawa to live with Cooney and Hamber in Burlington back in October 2017.

Both women were prospective adoptive parents but were not fully approved by CAS, as acknowledged by both parties. Cooney and Hamber received financial support through a provincial adoption initiative for the boys’ care.

While the boys remained under the guardianship of the Ottawa CAS, their family was monitored by Halton CAS.

Two boys stand in a doorway. The older boy is wearing a Spiderman costume.

L.L., left, was 16 months older than J.L., as indicated in court. They’re shown in a photo from years earlier. (Ontario Superior Court in Milton)

When they moved in with Cooney and Hamber, the older boy was six years old, approximately two years older than J.L. The Crown claims that during their time with the women, the boys were subjected to abuse and neglect.

The prosecution alleges that Cooney and Hamber confined the boys to their rooms, monitored them with cameras, compelled them to wear wetsuits, zip-tied their clothing and footwear, causing injuries, restricted their food intake, and forced them to exercise excessively.

Individuals involved in the boys’ lives, including a therapist and a teacher, noticed warning signs and, concerned for their welfare, alerted CAS, as stated by Frew. Nonetheless, the boys remained under the care of Cooney and Hamber for several years.

On the evening of December 21, 2022, Hamber made a 911 call to report that L.L. had ceased breathing, according to Frew.

Upon arrival, many of the firefighters, police officers, and paramedics believed the small, “emaciated” child lying on the floor of a cramped basement room was around six years old, Frew noted.

In reality, he was 12.

L.L. was found unresponsive in a puddle of water and was “left to die,” according to Frew.

A camera was positioned in the corner of the room, and the door was securely locked from the outside. The only furnishings in the room were a small mesh cot and a garbage can, she added.

He was quickly transported to the hospital with a dangerously low body temperature and passed away shortly after arrival.

Frew asserted that the women harbored “clear animosity” towards the brothers, particularly L.L.

The respective defence attorneys for Cooney and Hamber did not present opening statements.

CAS denied boys counselling, says foster mom

One of the key witnesses for the Crown was Heather Walsh, who, along with her husband, served as foster parents for L.L. starting when he was two and J.L. at 11 months old. CAS entrusted the boys to her care due to concerns regarding their biological parents’ home environment. Previously, the boys had been living with their grandparents.

According to Walsh, the older brother was “a very enthusiastic, social little guy,” despite experiencing speech delays and suffering from dental issues that required extensive repair work.

Walsh noted that he was clearly “very intelligent” and had taught himself to read novels by the age of six.

However, he could also exhibit aggressive behavior, hitting, kicking, and biting teachers as well as other children at daycare and kindergarten, and at times being “really rough” with his younger brother, sometimes intentionally, she reported.

During a camping trip, the older boy killed and mutilated a snake, raising concerns for Walsh about his behavior around family pets such as fish and rats. At one point, L.L. threatened to harm her and her family, as testified in court.

Walsh advocated for psychological counselling for the boys over several years, but CAS denied her requests repeatedly. She expressed her love for the boys and her commitment to keeping them in her home to prevent them from being shuffled between foster placements.

An attachment therapist eventually began working with them leading up to their adoption and subsequent relocation.

By the end of Grade 1, prior to L.L.’s move to Cooney and Hamber’s home, “he was settled and doing much better,” Walsh mentioned.

J.L. was characterized as shy, intelligent, and fond of animals and sports, particularly excelling in soccer, Walsh stated. He occasionally struggled to remain still, was a selective eater, and had a history of hitting adults.

However, he was generally thriving until the summer of 2017, when he discovered that he would be leaving Walsh and her husband, whom he referred to as “mama and daddy,” to move to Burlington to live with Cooney and Hamber.

J.L. “was really, really thrown by it,” Walsh recounted. “He was worried about leaving his friends and us behind.”

Defence asks witness about boy’s behaviour

Walsh ensured that Cooney and Hamber were informed about all aspects of the boys — both positive and negative — including behavioral challenges, L.L.’s occasional bedwetting, and his history of aggression.

As part of the adoption plan, she was to visit them every few months. However, Walsh stated that the last time she saw them was on December 10, after which the women severed all communication with her.

During cross-examination, the defence attorneys concentrated on L.L.’s behavior, his and J.L.’s reluctance to live with Cooney or Hamber, and the absence of CAS support.

Hamber’s attorney, Monte MacGregor, in his questioning of Walsh, labeled L.L. as “extraordinarily challenging,” even for her. He pointed out that Walsh had years of experience fostering children and working with those who had faced trauma.

“Yes, that’s accurate,” Walsh replied. “But, honestly, I believe there were children who were more difficult.”

She also expressed her belief that L.L. and J.L. could have been successfully adopted by a more suitable family.

“I think if someone else had adopted them, [L.L.] would be alive today,” Walsh stated.


If you’re affected by this report, you can seek mental health support through resources available in your province or territory.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Moose Collision Survivor Urges Caution as Wildlife Accidents Surge

Robert Belley credits a few metal bars on his...

Simu Liu Ties the Knot with Music Executive Allison Hsu in France

Canadian actor Simu Liu, known for his role in...

Explore the Surprising Life of the Ocean’s Strangest Fish: Sunfish!

When the term “ocean sunfish” comes to mind, you...

Amazon Resolves Major AWS Outage Disrupting Global Internet Services

Amazon has announced that a significant disruption to its...