The dominance of MMA on pay-per-view channels across North America is now a norm, but not long ago, it faced severe challenges, including being condemned by U.S. Sen. John McCain. Mark Kerr, known as the “Smashing Machine,” entered the arena as a formidable force, showcasing his unyielding power in the octagon. Despite his ferocity in combat, Kerr’s off-screen demeanor portrayed a stark contrast, a central theme in Benny Safdie’s film “The Smashing Machine.”
The film delves into a specific phase of Kerr’s tumultuous career, highlighting his rise, fall, and subsequent redemption. As Kerr basked in glory with championship belts and his wife Dawn by his side, the narrative took a turn towards his struggles, including a descent into pain pill addiction, missed opportunities, and strained relationships.
Kerr’s internal conflict between his combative persona inside the ring and his gentle demeanor outside it is a recurring theme in “The Smashing Machine.” The film explores the evolution of MMA from its early days with minimal rules to its contemporary regulated form. However, the narrative choice to focus on a transitional phase in Kerr’s career leaves some viewers questioning the missed opportunities to delve deeper into his compelling story.
Safdie’s approach in presenting Kerr’s life events as disjointed episodes fails to provide a cohesive storyline or a profound character examination. While Dwayne Johnson’s portrayal of Kerr is commendable, the lackluster script diminishes the impact of his performance. The film struggles to offer meaningful insights into Kerr’s persona or the sport’s dynamics, ultimately falling short of delivering a compelling narrative.
Despite its shortcomings, “The Smashing Machine” resonates with the enduring theme of a fighter grappling with personal demons and societal pressures. This archetype of a resilient athlete facing adversities has historically captivated audiences and garnered critical acclaim, echoing similar narratives in award-winning films centered on pugilists. The film’s portrayal of Kerr’s struggles adds to the cinematic legacy of depicting athletes’ triumphs and tribulations, a theme that has resonated with audiences for decades.
